Page 12 - November Merged
P. 12

Feature | Stop using ChatGPT




          BEST CHATBOT FOR RESEARCH


         For this test, we asked the AI assistants    Claude’s holiday itinerary
         to help us plan a holiday based on the   estimated the cost of each day
         criteria we provided. This allowed us to   and activity.
         see how thoroughly they would research
         our request and the level of detail and   screenshot). Claude included
         advice in their responses.         details of flights and the best
                                            time to go, and offered to
          PROMPT                            recommend specific hotels.
         Suggest a seven-day European holiday for   Copilot picked Ljubljana in
         someone who dislikes crowds and very   Slovenia and presented its
         hot weather, enjoys visiting cultural and   information in a similar way to
         historical sites, and has a $2,000 budget,   ChatGPT. It created an itinerary,
         excluding travel costs.            provided a ‘budget breakdown’ and
                                            suggested why that destination met our   its itinerary so we could “avoid feeling
         ChatGPT suggested a holiday in Porto    needs. Copilot also offered to create a   rushed” (a slight cop-out). It suggested
         in northern Portugal, and explained    new itinerary for cooler climates and   Norwich as an alternative.
         why it matched our preferences – with a   even quieter destinations.
         few photos to tempt us. It compiled a   Gemini surprised us by recommending   Winner: Claude
         seven-day itinerary, recommending   north Wales). It displayed a large Google
         things to see and do each day, calculated   map showing its suggested places to visit,   Claude gave us the most
         an approximate budget and suggested   including Conwy Castle and Portmeirion.   detailed itinerary, which
         alternatives including Estonia and   However, it didn’t provide a day-by-day   estimated the cost of each day and
         Poland.                            itinerary, a breakdown of costs, or   activity. We liked that ChatGPT made
           Claude recommended we visit Tallinn   alternative destinations for travelling   attraction names clickable so we could
         in Estonia – a “gem that ticks every box”.   further afield.            get more information, but it didn’t
         We liked the ‘accordion’ structure of its   Like Gemini, Perplexity assumed we   provide any practical advice. Gemini
         itinerary, which let us open each day in   wanted a holiday in the UK. It suggested   and Perplexity mysteriously assumed
         turn to see its suggested activities, places   we visit Durham for its cathedral and   we only wanted to visit the UK.
         to eat and how much it would cost us (see   museums, and included a ‘slow day’ in


          BEST CHATBOT FOR PRIVACY


         We thought the best way to test the AI                                chats will still be kept for 72 hours.
         tools’ privacy was to ask them directly if                              Weirdly, Perplexity sourced its answer
         they store our chat data and use it to train                          from OpenAI and Anthropic’s privacy
         their models. We could then see how                                   policies rather than its own. When we
         honestly they responded.                                              asked again for its specific terms, it said:
                                                                               “yes, consumer data can be used for
          PROMPT                                                               training unless you opt out” and
         Please summarise your data-retention                                  explained how to do so.
         policy. Explain whether my chat logs,                                   A much more reassuring response
         prompts and uploads are used to train                                 came from DuckDuckGo’s privacy-
         your AI models.                    Duck.ai doesn’t store your chats or use your   focused AI tool Duck.ai (www.duck.ai):
                                            data to train AI models.           “All user chats are completely
         ChatGPT said that, by default, it may use                             anonymous. DuckDuckGo does not
         our chats, prompts and files to improve   data to “improve the product experience”.   record any user chats. Chats are not used
         its AI models, but that we could disable   This contradicts Microsoft’s privacy policy,   to train or improve models.”
         the option under Data Controls. It   which confirms Copilot conversations are
         stressed that OpenAI “may still retain   used to “train our generative AI models”   Winner: Duck.ai
         some data” even when training is   (see tinyurl.com/APC563copolicy). It
         disabled.                          said data is retained for “only as long as   We didn’t include Duck.ai in our
           Claude told us our chats remain on its   needed”, whereas the privacy policy states   other tests because it’s not as powerful
         servers until deleted by us, then are   18 months.                      as the other contenders. However, for
         retained for 30 days before permanent   Gemini’s honest response said: “Yes, by   privacy it can’t be beaten. Every chat is
         deletion. It advised checking our Privacy   default, your conversations, prompts and   labelled ‘Zero data retention for this
         settings and disabling the ‘Help improve   uploaded files are used to train Google’s   chat. No AI training’ (see screenshot),
         Claude’ option to stop our data being   AI models.” It also confirmed chats are   so if you want to talk anonymously,
         used to train AI models.           stored for 18 months. Gemini explained   Duck.ai is the chatbot for you.
           Copilot promised it only uses our chat   how to stop both happening, but said
          42  APC MAGAZINE  OCTOBER 2026
   7   8   9   10   11   12   13