Page 9 - November Merged
P. 9

Feature | Stop using ChatGPT




          BEST CHATBOT FOR GENERATING IMAGES


         Our first image-generation test involved   spatial awareness, colour and lighting.   because AI often has trouble placing
         creating an original photo from a detailed   Our second test entailed generating a   people behind objects, and two signs we
         prompt. This was to gauge how accurately  composite image by placing the subject of   asked it to replace to test its text rendering.
         the AI chatbot could combine the   one photo on the background of another.   Claude doesn’t generate images, so we
         different elements in terms of realism,   The second picture included a barred gate   left it out of this round of testing.

          Prompt 1: Generating an original image

         Create a photo of a quiet countryside at sunrise, with rolling   crossing an undulating river. An older man is walking his Irish red
         green hills, a small cobblestone path, and an old wooden bridge   setter in the foreground.


         CHATGPT                                              COPILOT
         ChatGPT’s image                                      Copilot initially
         looked good on the                                   presented its
         surface, with all the                                image in a portrait
         requested details,                                   layout rather than
         but despite the depth                                landscape, so we
         of view it seemed a                                  asked it to adjust
         bit flat. Closer                                     this to match the
         inspection revealed                                  other tools. More
         the dog didn’t look like an Irish red setter and its back legs   disappointing was the yellow sheen, which may have been to
         appeared to be moving while its front legs were still. The paths   reflect the glow of sunrise but made the result look unmistakably
         in the background didn’t match the foreground and the river   AI. The composition of the picture was very similar to
         was flowing in two directions.                       ChatGPT’s, but with a more accurate Irish red setter.


         GEMINI                                               PERPLEXITY
         Gemini’s image was                                   Perplexity limits how
         the only one to                                      many images you
         actually look like a                                 can create for free
         genuine photo,                                       (we could only try
         foregoing AI design                                  once), and for the
         flourishes to focus                                  best results you need
         on realism. We liked                                 to pay for the
         the buildings and the                                advanced models of
         hills in the background, the detailed flora in the foreground and   its Pro plan. It warned us “this question looks difficult” but still
         the way the river opened out beyond the bridge. The man   produced a visually appealing image. The man, bridge and
         looked very lifelike, with a subtle smile and authentic clothes,   landscape looked pretty realistic, but the dead-eyed dog and
         and Gemini perfectly captured the panting Irish red setter.   unnecessary mist were giveaway signs of AI.

          Prompt 2: Combining two images

         Combine these images so the subject of the first photo looks   CHATGPT
         trapped behind the gate of the second photo (both below).   ChatGPT did a seamless
         Replace the ‘private parking’ signs with ‘danger keep out’ and   job of combining the
         ‘enter at own risk’.                                 two images, but again
                                                              there was a flat quality
                                                              to the result that
                                                              stopped it from looking
                                                              real. This wasn’t helped
                                                              by how it positioned the
                                                              subject behind the
                                                              middle black bar, which
                                                              made it look like one
                                                              ear was separate from
                                                              his head. We were more
                                                              impressed by its
                                                              authentic-looking
                                                              signs.
                                                                                     OCTOBER 2026  APC MAGAZINE  39
   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12   13